LED Light Project Update

As I discussed last year in the spring, I have been contemplating for some time changing over the incandescent bulbs on my motorcycle to LED.  Due to a recent test run of a 90 watt electric heated vest, I have determined that I need to go ahead with the LED conversion project.  Also in light of my impending fuel injection conversion project, it is time to upgrade.  Thus tonight I placed an order on Amazon for LED bulbs to replace every incandescent on the bike.  The table below shows what I purchased and how much I paid.

 

NOTE:

Bulb Description Qty Generic Bulb Lens Color Amazon Bulb Description Reported LED Color LED Cost Shipping Costs
Tail Light 2 1157 Red 2pcs 1157 Bay15D 18 SMD 5050 LED STOP BRAKE TAIL LIGHT BULBS 12V-RED Red $18.99♠ $5.99
Center Brake/License Plate Light 1 T10 Red/Clear 4x 194 168 5-SMD White High Power LED Car Lights Bulb ♣ White $9.98 Free
Rear Turn Signal 2 1156 Amber 2 of LED 2W 12V White Omni Bulb BA15S 1156 P21W Brake Tail 18 5050 SM ♥ White $4.99 $2.74
Front Turn Signal 2 1157 Amber 2 of LED 2W 12V White Omni Bulb BAY15D 1157 P21W Brake Tail 18 5050 S ♥ White $4.99 $2.74
Dash Lights 10 T10 Varies 4x 194 168 5-SMD White High Power LED Car Lights Bulb ♣ White $9.98 Free
Notes:

♠The Amazon page indicates that I should receive a pair of bulbs.

♣These come in packs of four. The center brake/license plate light and instrument cluster use the same bulbs.  The bike needs a total of 11 bulbs of this type.

♥These are supposed to come in packs of two.  I only could find a white LED bulb in this style on Amazon rather than amber.  Hopefully they will perform as expected.

 

The total including shipping for the order came to $78.41.  This price is only for the LED bulbs and does not include the electronic flasher that I will need to ensure that my turn signals blink at the proper rate.  I chose to hold off on buying that until I have the bike’s tupperwear off and can properly investigate the self-canceling turn signal system.  It appears that I will be replacing a three pin flasher relay but I might also need to replace a four pin latching relay.  Further investigation will need to be performed when I have the bike apart and am able to access the electronics.  I suspect that I might need to isolate the turn signal self-cancel unit with relays and use some resistors to show the unit the amount of resistance it expects to see when a full set of incandescent bulbs are present.  If I somehow manage to destroy the self canceling turn signal module, I might end up building my own solution using some spare parts I have lying around.  Hopefully I can make the existing module work with LEDs though.  The wattage savings will be worth my trouble.

As I continue with this project, I will post updates on my blog.  Watch this website for more details.

LED Light Project Notes for the PC800

NOTE: If someone sees an error in the tables or anywhere else, PLEASE LET ME KNOW! 🙂

NOTE: Juan informs me that Kevin Quosig did a conversion several years ago where he replaced the incandescent bulbs with home-brewed LED arrays.  See the updates at the bottom for information on this.

NOTE: See the bottom for a few updates.

I’ve been mulling over converting my PC800 to LED lights for everything but the headlight for over a year.  The main reasons I didn’t do the conversion last year in the winter were:

  1. LED Bulbs at the time weren’t to the standards I wanted.  Many were too large to fit into the PC’s lens assemblies and also did not have particularly good lumen output.
  2. Reports of the self-canceling turn signal unit going bad as a result of an LED conversion scared me away as the self-canceling turn signal unit is rather expensive and difficult to replace.
  3. I was having difficulty determining what bulbs the PC takes without actually removing the bulbs from the bike.

Now that there is at least one positive LED conversion with good results and no fried self-canceling turn signal, I’m thinking about doing the conversion again.  Also, I anticipate needing all the extra watts I can get to run the fuel injection conversion project that I have in the works.

The bulbs for the PC800 aren’t immediately identifiable in the microfiche, owners manual, or service manual as far as I can tell.  To aid in determining what generic type of bulb goes where, I’ve put together the following table.

Bulb Description Voltage Wattage Qty Microfiche Ref # Part # Honda Code Generic Bulb Lens Color
Tail Light 12 Volts 27/7 Watts ♠ 2 H1 7 34906-MG9-771 1700301 1157 Red
Center Brake/License Plate Light 12 Volts 5 Watts 1 H1 6 34901-SB0-671 1481845 T10 Red/Clear ♣
Rear Turn Signal 12 Volts 23 Watts 2 G12 13 34905-268-671 0145318 1156 Amber
Front Turn Signal 12 Volts 23/8 Watts ♠ 2 G12 14 34906-313-671 0460485 1157 Amber
Meter Light 12 Volts 3.4 Watts 10 E4 1 34908-GA7-701
37102-567-009
37237-SA5-003
37237-SA5-004
1084672
0846436
1294925
1294966
T10 Clear ♥
Notes:
♠ Low wattage under normal running conditions, high wattage when brake pedal is depressed or turn signal is active.
♣ The brake light portion of the lens assembly is red while the part that illuminates the license plate is clear.  If replacing with an LED bulb, I would suggest getting a clear LED assembly rather than a red assembly so that the license plate light is illuminated with a neutral color.  A clever person could install white LEDs in place of the license plate lens assembly though.
♥ I suspect that, if replacing the incandescent bulbs with LED equivalents, interesting effects could be had by using colored LEDs.

The IPCRCer who has recent successful conversion to LED lights brought up an interesting point regarding the PC’s turn signal flasher unit.  They will blink faster with LED bulbs rather than incandescent bulbs.  One way to fix this is to put resistors into the circuits in order to match wattage with the old incandescent bulbs.  This is fine and dandy if you only want the benefits of having very long-lived bulbs with a nearly instantaneous response time.  However, it doesn’t help matters much if you want to save some watts for extra heated gear or whatever other sorts of electrical farkles you’ve been coveting.

In order to correct the hyperactive flashing that replacing the incandescent bulbs with LEDs will cause, replacement of the turn signal relay and position light relay is necessary.  I am told that automotive flasher units aren’t direct drop-in replacements but that with some wiring, they can be.  I haven’t quite puzzled through the existing circuit design yet but evidently, some people on some Goldwing forums have already figured it out.  When I find appropriate links, I will update this post.

The recent conversion to LED used 68 SMD LED bulbs purchased (it appears) from E-Bay seller USHD.  I will confirm that they came from this seller shortly.  Rather than worry about shoddy products from Hong Kong, this seller appears to be located in the USA.  An initial email to them was answered within a day.  Shipping is a little expensive but I’m willing to pay it if they have a quality product.  The one thing they are missing but inform me that will be available again in a couple weeks is a clear T10-style bulb.

Going off of the “Buy it Now” price on E-Bay, the cost breakdown will be as follows:

— LED Bulbs —
Bulb Description QTY Unit Price Total Cost
Tail Light † 2 $13.99 $27.98
Center Brake/License Plate Light 1 ♦ $9.99 ♠ $9.99
Rear Turn Signal ‡ 2 $13.99 $27.98
Front Turn Signal ◊ 2 $13.99 $27.98
Meter Light 10 ♦ $9.99 ♠ $49.95
Sub Total: $143.88
— Shipping —
Unit # QTY Shipped Price / Unit Shipped Total Cost
First Unit 1 $3.49 $3.49
Additional Units 11 $0.99 $10.89
Sub Total: $14.38
Grand Total: $158.26
Notes:
♠ Sold in packs of 2.  Unit price is actually for a 2-pack.  You will have one extra T10-style bulb purchasing it this way.  Also, this price is for a 8 SMD-style LED bulb.  The currently available T10-style bulbs from E-Bay seller USHD are of a different style and are less expensive.  However, they are currently not available in clear/white.  The $9.99 price comes from an email exchange I had with USHD.  I do not know if that will be the “Buy it Now” price when they become available on E-Bay in a few weeks of writing this post.
♦ Quantity given in total number of bulbs.  Sold on E-Bay through USHD in packs of 2.  You will need to buy 6 packs of T10-style bulbs total for both the center brake/license plate light and the meter lights if buying 2-packs.
† Description on USHD’s E-Bay store: 1157 Red 68 SMD LED Light Bulb Turn/Tail 2057A 2357A
‡ Description on USHD’s E-Bay store: 1156 Amber 68 SMD LED Light Bulb Turn/Tail 1141A 3497A
◊ Description on USHD’s E-Bay store: 1157 Amber 68 SMD LED Light Bulb Turn/Tail 2057A 2357A

Throw in another $50 for miscellaneous parts needed to convert the turn signal and position light relays over to electronic automotive flasher and standard relays and an LED conversion project is pushing $200 total.  But the real question for me: how many watts will be saved with this conversion?

Bulb Description QTY Incandescent Watts / Unit ‡ Total Incandescent Watts ‡ LED Watts / Unit † Total LED Watts †
Tail Light 2 27/7 Watts ♥ 54/14 Watts ♥ 5/?? Watts ♥ ◊ 10/?? Watts ♥ ◊
Center Brake/License Plate Light 1 5 Watts 5 Watts 1 Watt 1 Watt
Rear Turn Signal 2 23 Watts 46 Watts 5 Watts 10 Watts
Front Turn Signal 2 23/8 Watts ♥ 46/16 Watts ♥ 5/?? Watts ♥ ◊ 10/?? Watts ♥ ◊
Meter Light 10 3.4 Watts 34 Watts 1 Watt ♣ 10 Watts ♣
Total Watts: 185/155/69/65Watts ♦ ‡ Total Watts: 41/??/31/27 Watts ♦ ♣ ◊
Total Watt Savings: 144/??/38/38 Watts ♦ ♣ ◊ † ‡
Notes:
♥ These bulbs have “high” and “low” modes.  The larger wattage draw is during the “high” condition.  This happens when a turn signal or the brakes are activated.
♦ The first number represents the maximum potential load on the system if all lights are on.  To achieve this, the brakes, both turn signals, and all of the indicator lights would have to be on.  This could be seen if you have a hazard light modification installed to allow both blinkers to blink simultaneously.  The second number is the normally seen maximum wattage when the brakes and one turn signal are activated along with all of the indicator lights.  This could happen if you were pulled over at the side of the road with the engine off, kick stand down, transmission in neutral, and high beams on.  The third number is the normal operating condition of the bike.  This would be with the engine running, kickstand up, no turn signals activated, no brake activation, and low headlight beam.  The fourth number represents the minimum wattage the bike sees and what the average PCer would have on a normal ride.
♣ The wattage for the new T10-style LED bulbs that E-Bay seller USHD will shortly offer on E-Bay is not yet know.  I am guessing, based upon the currently-offered T10-style LED bulbs, that the new bulbs will use 1 Watt or less.
◊ The “low” condition isn’t known for the LED bulbs because USHD’s website does not list them.
† This assumes that what is reported on E-Bay seller USHD’s auctions for wattage characteristics of the LED bulbs is accurate.
‡ This assumes that the wattage information provided in the PC800 Microfiche is accurate.

The take-away from all of this is that (theoretically) 38 watts at normal operation conditions can be saved.  That’s a pretty significant savings.  For comparison, a pair of Gerbing T-5 gloves uses 27 watts at maximum load.  Considering my fuel injection project will most likely consume many more watts than the 38 watts that a full LED conversion could potentially save, it seems like a smart move for me if I start getting pinched for watts.  However, I think with the high cost of the full conversion, I might wait until I determine that I really need to switch to LED to squeeze a few more available watts out of the PC800’s electrical system.

UPDATES:

At least one IPCRCer reports converting his entire bike over to LED for $75 and did not need to replace his flasher.  I am waiting for more information on what bulbs he used and where he bought them.

Seth suggests checking out http://www.superbrightleds.com/ and http://www.ledtronics.com/ for good additional information and high-quality LED bulbs.  He says that you get what you pay for.  I looked into these two companies a year ago when I considered converting before.  At the time I wasn’t impressed with their product listings.  It looks like they have some new stuff that is a bit better.  Their prices are higher than what I listed in the tables above.  Seth also suggests going with color-matched bulbs.

The point was brought up by Seth that any extra watts have to go somewhere due to the PC alternator’s configuration.  They get dumped into the R/R which could be looked at as a consumable item.  This gives me the idea of hooking up some extra resistors on the bike to dissipate extra power when I don’t have a full loading case.  Throwing on some simple circuitry to monitor voltage to enable or disable power resistors would make it all automated.  Or a high-power MOSFET might work…

The Kevin Quosig LED conversion project appears to have been quite the feat.  He started with converting his Uni-Go trailer to using LED arrays sourced from Custom Dynamics.  The steps to his Uni-Go conversion are here: Step 1, Step 2, Step 3, Step 3.5, end results of the Uni-Go conversion.  The steps to his PC conversion are here: Step 1, Step 2, Step 3, Step 4, Step 5, end results of the PC800 conversion.  The total cost of the entire conversion was approximately $1000.  Yes one thousand dollars.  Kevin thinks it was worth it though.  I would suspect with the reduction in price of high quality, high output LEDs since 2004, this project could be done much more inexpensively today.  Especially if you were to build your own array boards.